How Important Are Amazon Reviews – A Guide for Sellers

Updated on October 16, 2025
Illustration of a person sitting on an office chair using a laptop. Speech bubbles show a thumbs-up icon and star ratings. Text on the left asks, How important are Amazon reviews? Shopping bags are on the floor.

It goes without saying that as an Amazon seller, you heavily depend on customer reviews to increase your reputation and convince other potential buyers to get your products. You know customer reviews are important, but how important are they, actually?

Here’s the reality: reviews are far more than just star ratings and numbers on product listings. They’re a powerful force that shapes your visibility, sales, and long-term success on Amazon. Keep reading to learn more about how Amazon reviews can affect your store, how to handle reviews, and how to improve your store based on what you learn from them.

How Amazon Reviews Affect You

84% of Amazon sellers surveyed believe that reviews are very important to their business. It’s hardly surprising since Amazon displays the average review ratings on your product listing and when you search for products. After the product’s name and picture, the next thing buyers will likely see is the review score.

Effect of Reviews on Buyers

The better reviews a product has, the more attractive it looks to potential buyers. That much is certain, but it’s often not that straightforward. Sometimes, people may prefer a 4.5-star item with hundreds of reviews than a 5-star item with only a dozen reviews. Often, people look at the number of reviews as well as the score itself. Generally speaking, high scores with lots of reviews are the gold standard since people know that lots of people liked the product.

In addition to scores, some Amazon reviews hold more weight than others. Verified reviews from people who bought the product on Amazon are generally more trusted because it’s proven that they already bought the item they wrote about. Amazon Vine reviewers are also more trusted because Amazon only invites trustworthy, consistent review writers to be part of the program.

Amazon’s Review Algorithm

Unfortunately, Amazon keeps its review and product ranking algorithm tightly under wraps. However, based on experience and observation, we do know several factors impact how well a product ranks based on the Amazon algorithm. 

Factors that impact your product rankings include, but aren’t limited to:

  • Customer feedback and reviews: The better reviews your products get, the more visible it is on the search results.
  • Product sales velocity: Fast-selling products often gain more visibility on search results.
  • Key terms in product title: More descriptive titles that include the brand name, variant, color, and useful details often rank better.
  • High-quality product images: Appealing product images help customers make snap judgments to check out a product, helping it rank higher.
  • Product description optimization: Often, product descriptions in bullet points are more appealing because they’re easier to read and skim.

Essentially, the easier a product listing is for potential buyers to skim and understand, the more likely that product is going to rank high on Amazon search results.

Improving Your Store Based on Customer Reviews

Reviews aren’t just good for increasing your product visibility on Amazon. They’re also very useful to improve your Amazon store. Reviewers often drop insights and observations that you may not have thought about. That kind of feedback is very valuable for you to improve your storefront and business.

Graphic titled improving your store based on reviews with a checklist: modify products for complaints, stock requested products, identify issues via sentiment. Illustrates a woman pushing a shopping cart on a giant smartphone.
How Important Are Amazon Reviews – Improving Your Store

Let’s say you found a lot of reviews criticizing your product’s short battery life. The next time you develop a new product or revamp existing ones, you can improve the battery life to address those complaints.

Reviews can also be a good source of market research information. By examining what your customers need or want, you can develop or stock products that complement your existing offerings to sell more stuff.

Building a Strong Review Profile

We know how important Amazon customer reviews are. As a seller, naturally, you want to have a lot of high-quality, preferably positive reviews. How do you accomplish that? Definitely not by buying reviews because that’s a big no-no under Amazon regulations.

One of the simplest ways you can generate more reviews is to ask customers who bought your products. You can send emails asking them to leave a review or even place thank-you cards in each package you send to ask them for reviews.

Illustration showing a person interacting with a large smartphone displaying a 5-star review. Text reads: how to get more product reviews on amazon: ask customers to leave reviews, offer incentives like loyalty programs, send emails through the request a review button.
How Important Are Amazon Reviews – How to Get Reviews

Amazon prohibits bribing for reviews, but you can offer incentives that don’t involve bribery, like loyalty programs and discounts for subsequent purchases. While this is more for fostering customer satisfaction, happy customers are often happy to leave reviews.

Another good way is to use the “request a review” button from your seller page. It sends an automated email to the customer requesting their review and seller feedback. It’s automated, so it might lack personalization compared to the methods detailed above, but it’s still worth a try.

Handling Reviews Effectively

Customer reviews are important, but the way you handle reviews is equally important. It’s easy to show your appreciation when the reviews are positive and put your products in a good light. However, it might be hard to stay neutral when customers review your products badly.

Getting angry at customers for posting bad reviews reflects horribly on you, and it may drive customers away. If you see a negative customer review, approach it with the intention to identify the problem and help solve it if you can. 

While you can probably deal with real negative reviews civilly, fake reviews are another thing. They’re often written specifically to damage your reputation, so nothing you say can help. However, you can use an Amazon review checker first to confirm if that horrible review is fake or violates Amazon policy. If that’s the case, that review can be reported for removal.

Conclusion

Reviews are more than just social proof on Amazon. They’re a cornerstone of seller success that impacts everything from search rankings to conversion rates. While they’re very important, you should still respect Amazon’s guidelines as you navigate customer reviews.

It’s not all about achieving perfect 5-star ratings or accumulating hundreds of reviews overnight. Instead, it’s about fostering genuine customer relationships, responding professionally to feedback, and using review insights to continuously improve your offerings. 

Got problems with fake reviews? TraceFuse has your back. Our AI tools will handle the entire fake review removal process and you can expect those abusive, reputation-damaging reviews to start being reported within just a few days.

Best of all, our services are 100% white-hat, regulation-compliant! You don’t need to worry about getting penalized by Amazon if you work with us. Schedule a demo call today to start cleaning up your product review section.